Enkrod

joined 5 months ago
[–] Enkrod 2 points 3 months ago* (last edited 3 months ago)

The term is greek in origin and referred to burn offering "holókaustos" - "completely/wholely burned", it was used in this way throughout the middle ages for fire-progroms against Jews (*) and later (1515) to decry the witch-burnings as "the new fire sacrifices" ("nova holocausta").

* "Eodem coronationis die, circa illam sollemnitatis horam qua Filius immolabatur Patri, incceptum est in civitate Londoniae immolare Judaeos patri suo diabolo ; tantaque fuit hujus Celebris mora mysterii, ut vix altera die compleri potuerit holocaustum" - "On the same day of the coronation, about that solemn hour when the Son was sacrificed to the Father, it was begun in the city of London to sacrifice the Jews to their father the devil; and so great was the delay of this famous mystery, that the next day the holocaust could scarcely have been completed" source

Edit: This is btw. describing the events of the coronation of Richard the Lionheart 1189 CE.

[–] Enkrod 3 points 3 months ago* (last edited 3 months ago)

While I do agree with you on a general level, I think this is largely a discussion about how different cultures and languages use the word holocaust.

In Germany, the word Holocaust has a connotation that particularly emphasizes the exceptional nature of the event in comparison to everything that has happened before and since.

This connotation is not necessarily present in other societies, where the meaning is closer to the Greek root ‘holókaustos’ - ‘completely burnt, destroyed’ and this results in the difference between the Holocaust and a holocaust in English.

It is therefore understandable that the term holocaust is used in other languages for what is happening.

Is it helpful though? Here's my - slightly different - take of why using the word is not necessarily wrong... but unhelpful.

I myself prefer the term "genocide" in the Israeli-Palestinian context, especially because the term holocaust in close proximity to Judaism is extremely loaded and in this context has connotations that are less about Israel's terrible crimes and more about the somewhat conspiratorial accusation of ‘victims becoming perpetrators’ against Jews as a whole, which resonates with antisemitism and understandably gives rise to accusations of antisemitism to the point of completely losing focus of the important part of the discussion:

The state of Israel is committing extended, organized and deliberate genocide against Palestinians, out of hatred of and revenge against Hamas. This hatred and revenge against Hamas is justified. Targeting innocent Palestinians is not.

One can call this a holocaust, but this choice of word is more likely to derail the discussion and serve an entirely different agenda than the one that tries to achieve some end of the murders in Israel, Gaza and the West Bank.

[–] Enkrod 7 points 3 months ago
[–] Enkrod 10 points 3 months ago

I think he's saying that democracy (equalizing political power) has been the political consensus in the US since WW2.

And he's obviously against it.

[–] Enkrod 3 points 3 months ago

Wanted to comment about He Who Fights with Monsters, I'm currently listening to Book 11 and am a little bit in awe how the protagonist is somehow extremely powerful but at the same time the writer still manages to keep him out of the "overpowered protagonist"-trap.

He's still the same old likeable Aussie we met in book 1 but has gone through some powerful character arcs.

Definitely my favourite LitRPG/Isekai book series.

[–] Enkrod 24 points 3 months ago
[–] Enkrod 5 points 3 months ago

It's EUA in french (États-Unis d'Amérique)

[–] Enkrod 19 points 3 months ago (2 children)

You know these ventriloquism-routines where the puppet makes the puppeteer talk with it's voice?

[–] Enkrod 2 points 3 months ago

It's so weird that Akira Kurosa, reknowned for his Samurai movies, was such a huge influence on western cinema as a whole and the western genre in particular, but once you watch his work and realize when he did it and that some of the best known western tropes today originate in his works... everything just clicks into place.

[–] Enkrod 30 points 3 months ago

In our bed?!

view more: ‹ prev next ›