"I want to read comment sections on anime episodes, I must know what anime fans have to say" - statements dreamed up by the utterly Deranged
this post was submitted on 09 Jul 2024
196 points (96.2% liked)
Technology
34175 readers
51 users here now
This is the official technology community of Lemmy.ml for all news related to creation and use of technology, and to facilitate civil, meaningful discussion around it.
Ask in DM before posting product reviews or ads. All such posts otherwise are subject to removal.
Rules:
1: All Lemmy rules apply
2: Do not post low effort posts
3: NEVER post naziped*gore stuff
4: Always post article URLs or their archived version URLs as sources, NOT screenshots. Help the blind users.
5: personal rants of Big Tech CEOs like Elon Musk are unwelcome (does not include posts about their companies affecting wide range of people)
6: no advertisement posts unless verified as legitimate and non-exploitative/non-consumerist
7: crypto related posts, unless essential, are disallowed
founded 5 years ago
MODERATORS
There have been several shows that I’ve watched on CR that have been made a lot better by being able to read the comments section. Either because it’s One Piece and there’s always one guy giving you the timestamp to skip the recap or because the series I’m watching is actually pretty bad and a bunch of people are making jokes at the shows expense.
It’s been rare that I’ve seen someone on CR be overly negative or toxic without getting shutdown fast. It’s usually pretty wholesome and fun.
That was one of My favorite things about Crunchyroll. I love going through the comments after finishing a series and seeing what others were thinking. I know anime fans can be pretty crazy, but I very rarely saw toxic comments. It was mostly people talking about a shared experience and was surprisingly wholesome the majority of the time. I even got some good recommendations about what to watch next because of it too
Just to hazard a guess, it might be pretty closely moderated to keep the toxicity down. That might just be costing Crunchyroll more than they think it's worth.
this is exactly it; anytime you see a really wholesome comment section, it's because they have a team to actually moderate it which costs time and money
Never really thought about that but that makes a lot of sense.
This is crunchyroll, it was probably not moderated at all.
They banned someone for a few weeks who'd comment Dub time on dubs after some weirdos got irrationally angry about it and mass reported her. There'd also be a meaningful comment on the actual episode from the same user, but it wouldn't be upvoted as much, so wouldn't be displayed as prominently. Before the ban and after it was reversed, there'd typically be an argument in the replies to the Dub time comment between people angrily ranting about it and other people defending it.
So there clearly was some moderation, but beyond an automated bad word filter, and I guess something blocking URLs, it was done sparingly and reluctantly.
In that case they should've added AI based mod tools instead of just turning them off.
Maybe you can get the same experience at a place llike AniList or Kitsu?
Good. Not every website needs to be a social media platform too. There's already plenty of communities on the Internet to discuss anime.
Bad.
Censoring culture is not good, making it so the only place to get news is from paid talking heads who would never bite the hand that feeds, is not a good change.
The community is destroyed.
This isn't censoring culture. This is a streaming platform focusing on streaming and giving up on trying to be more than that.
The communities still exist and will find a new platform. Just over a year ago there was a sizeable chunk of Redditors that came to Lemmy. It's happened time after time when a platform goes down. Communities are much more than just the platform they are on.
I've just cancelled my Crunchyroll sub, not only because of the user content deletion but because they lock many translations and animes out of Spain and the quality of some subs are shit generated with AI. My new streaming service is nyaa.
The amount of people bootlicking a corporation's decision to cut costs rather than just moderate effectively is pretty astonishing for Lemmy,
Plenty of people got value out of the comment section - if nothing else, they were invaluable in knowing when to skip past the recap/opening theme/filler content in long-running shows like One Piece.
Most of it is pretty inane, but there was some useful stuff in there, and I always found it fun to see what other people thought of particularly crazy episodes.
This saddens me. The comments of the animes I watched usually had some interesting trivia or background information that I had missed.
Super useful for something like Overlord, where scenes with background information were cut and there'd be someone saying what else you'd know by this point in the manga, or if you'd forgotten something since watching a previous season and needed a reminder.
you can still use MAL with malsync browser extension and then you can get decent reviews you need
“Protecting our community," by destroying it. If you don't have a community, then it can't be toxic. Were the comments so bad that this was the only solution?
Most streaming services don’t do comment sections. That’s mostly a YouTube and TikTok thing where the sites depend on user submitted content and also function as a social network. Despite this, people talk about shows on those services, just elsewhere.
Most streaming services don't have a 'community'.
You're a netflix customer, not a part of a community. There is no Netflix or Amazon, etc community.
YouTube has a community though.
See how that works?
it definitely helps that anime tends to be niche and not mainstream (though there's still some toxicity, ofc).
What, you can't have war if there are no people?
There is no ~~war in~~ Ba Sing Se.
have you seen literally any comments section lately?
Most comment sections under crunchyroll episodes are super wholesome and cheerful, people are mostly celebrating how good the episode was and how cool the next ones will be.
I meant besides crunchyroll... but are you trying to imply that they shouldn't have done this or that their harmful content is not a problem that should be dealt with?
Comments dont make money, moderation costs money. So pull it and make the site more like the other streaming services out there, make some PR word salad to justify it. Not surprising really. Of course maybe it really was a Salty Spitoon in the comments section. Either way, not exactly the burning of the Library of Alexandria.
Omfg the comment section lovers are literally a vocal minority, this is kinda silly to see play out.
Just another reason to sail the seas.
the high seas have a comment section?
if (postTitle.contains(anyStreamingService)) postPiracyPropaganda();
Yeah, lots of illegal anime streaming sites have MAL list import, comment sections, forums, etc.
i mean if you go to crunchyroll just for the comment section and not to actually watch movies... sure?
Why can’t I do both.
No thoughtcrime, only consume.
Crunchyroll has a comment section? I had seem ratings but never looked at the comments
Harmful to Sony's bottom line.
And nothing of value was lost.
It would be nice if those comments were moderated, but mostly what I saw in crunchy roll comments was straight up fascist propaganda. I'm in a place where I'm like... Not everything needs a comment section. I can take the criticism this makes me a crunchy roll bootlicker. I'll take that L, but know this: we should all be pirating stuff all the time given how the big corporations treat our art and creations