The api is kind of irrelevant. Scraping is possible for any public site. This shouldn't be a reason to close off access.
this post was submitted on 28 Nov 2024
13 points (78.3% liked)
Technik
330 readers
43 users here now
die Community für alles, was man als Technik beschreiben kann
Beiträge auf Deutsch oder Englisch
founded 5 months ago
MODERATORS
Makes you wonder who stands to gain (or lose less) by a message like this
Feels like a hit piece
That is kind of how the open Internet works. AI or no AI, the rules have been the same for years.
If you put anything online, it is no longer under your control and fancy APIs just remove a step or two in collecting that data.
Scraper do not ask, scraper just scrape.
Got news for anyone using Lemmy….
Well, is there's no API, people complain that it's too closed. If there is an API, people complain that it's too open. If you don't want AI to see and use your data, don't post it publicly. Attaching a license or terms could make clear what can and cannot be done with the data, but enforcement will be hard.
My opinion is that having an API is preferable, because anything that is put out there publicly can already be scraped anyway, but an API makes 3rd party clients and other integrations possible, which is a good thing.
There is a solution but everyone rants about it to: DRM. The problem is it’s been used in a way that no one likes and thus says it’s evil and restricted. But in this case it could be used to limit who can do what with the data. Granted there are always ways around it like the analog loophole
I don't believe DRM is the solution here, since it's the public posts that are being scraped. Those public posts are by default visible by everybody, so scrapers can't be stopped with DRM, unless you want to make a platform that can only be accessed by trusted applications.
You're not really into this whole technology thing much, are you?
If there's an API, you don't scrape data. Scraping is when you take the data out of some HTML file meant for human consumption. Maybe they should leave more of the writing to AI.
and its not really decentralized because the main server controls who can enter the network.
Did bluesky say anything about this? Because if yes, ill bet my shiny metal ass that tthey are going to paywall the api in 2025