this post was submitted on 10 Aug 2024
195 points (98.5% liked)
Ukraine
8285 readers
583 users here now
News and discussion related to Ukraine
*Sympathy for enemy combatants is prohibited.
*No content depicting extreme violence or gore.
*Posts containing combat footage should include [Combat] in title
*Combat videos containing any footage of a visible human must be flagged NSFW
Server Rules
- Remember the human! (no harassment, threats, etc.)
- No racism or other discrimination
- No Nazis, QAnon or similar
- No porn
- No ads or spam
- No content against Finnish law
Donate to support Ukraine's Defense
Donate to support Humanitarian Aid
founded 2 years ago
MODERATORS
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
Is this a separate incursion or an extension of the Kursk invasion? Belgorod is a separate region, correct?
Belgorod is the oblast next to Kursk. Its both a separate region and an extension of the Kursk incursion. Part of what I'm reading in other places is that the stunning success of this operation can partially be accounted to Russian partisans treating the Ukrainian forces as liberators and sabotaging Russia's ability to reinforce in the region. By expanding the zone of control, Ukraine is solidifying their territorial gains. I don't know what comes next, but it seems like almost no one, not even many Ukrainians, thought they had this in them. Russia has been caught severely with its pants down and Ukraine has shown that they have much more fight in them left than many realized.
Their situation remains precarious as an entire nation, but it seems that Russia's situation was far more precarious than anyone outside of Ukraine's inner circle realized. Further, this is a true win for Ukrainian intelligence. No one knew. The only people who did were local Russian military intelligence people who either didn't properly report what they were seeing, or weren't listened to. It seems clear from this that Ukraine's intelligence mechanisms are accurate and devoid of leaks. I don't know that any other nation can truly say that. That to me is the most stunning part of this.
I feel it’s more realistic that they can maintain good opsec and use obfuscation and misdirection to cover the slips. I know that sounds pedantic, but the last few feet are the most crucial, and something will always leak. The key is to mix the real leaks with false ones, so they get lost in the noise.
All speculation, but I bet other rotated units have been sent to this area in the past, and other potential incursion points, to make it seem a safe recovery zone and nothing odd was happening. They probably have the russian liberation group specifically training somewhere else near the boarder. I know none of us are planning invasions of the porous boarders of our paper tiger neighbors, but this can apply to regular life as well.
Thanks for the comments. By separate incursion, I mean - are they entering Russia through a completely separate area of the Russian border? It is it an offshoot of the other forces, entering Belgorod through Russian territory.
This really does change the strategy of the whole war, especially if they can hold it even expand their the gains.
I would also imagine other countries bordering Russia might take notice.
It would be kinda funny if Finland started moving stuff toward the border near St. Petersburg, just to troll putin / make him waste resources in kind.
All NATO nations should bring troops to the border and start drilling until Russia exits Ukraine.
Just keep Russia on 24/7 alert at all times until their economy collapses
Russia has left the border with Finland undefended for at least a year...
Correct, the Russian border has become quite porous.
So is this a separate incursion?
Yes, but the scale is unknown.
Wow. This is a very interesting development. Thanks for the update! Discussions about Ukraine is one thing I miss from Reddit.
Yeah I went to check out the old Ukrainian Conflict subreddit the day I saw the Kursk counter invasion news drop in this community since there wasn’t much discussion here. There were more comments there, but absolutely nothing of substance.
Belgorod and Kurak are different provinces/states but beside eachother. I think Ukraine planned this as a smash and run. As Kursk has a major pipeline control and if they destroyed it Russia could not move oil from the east. But we're surprised by there success and kept pushing. But grain of salt as it's just a theory.
From what I've read the degree of partisan support they've received outstripped their expectations. Russia's lack of effective response has been a surprise, as has been the willingness of the populace to either help or at least not get in the way.
This event has been a total failure of Russian intelligence and a complete success for Ukrainian intelligence. And I want to emphasize. Ukraine does not share credit for this intelligence success. The degree of trust and cohesion throughout its military apparatus has by just been shown to be the strongest in the world. There was no talk of Ukraine invading the oblasts to their north until it had already happened