I can provide some info about TD, Simplii, Tangerine, EQ, and Wealthsimple (more of an investing service than a bank):
Online Banking Experience:
- TD: Webapp works but is not pretty. App is more polished.
- Simplii: Webapp is similar to TD in lack of polish. Mobile app is similar to the other two above.
- Tangerine: Webapp is a bit better than the above two. App is more polished.
- EQ: Webapp is a bit more polished like Tangerine. Mobile app is a little worse than the above but still fine.
- Wealthsimple: Probably the best webapp and mobile app experience.
Credit Cards (Ease of Use):
- TD: Many credit card options and can automate payments for it from any institution (I believe).
- Simplii: They have a free card that has 4% back on restaurants which is pretty cool. Can be automated from other institutions.
- Tangerine: They have a very cool free credit card (2% back on 2-3 user selected categories). Annoyingly though, you can't automate payments using another institution.
- EQ: No idea about credit cards.
- Wealthsimple: I believe they just released a new credit card. No idea how good it is.
Fees:
- TD: They have an account that if you keep a minimum $5000 in it, there are no fees and you get some extra perks (free premium credit card, etc.). Other than that, the free account with no minimum is pretty limited.
- Simplii: Free accounts and credit cards.
- Tangerine: Free accounts and credit cards.
- EQ: Free accounts. Not sure about credit cards.
- Wealth simple: Free account. Not sure about credit card.
Etransfers:
- TD: etransfers have a fee but is waived if you hit the minimum in the account.
- Simplii: free
- Tangerine: free
- EQ: free
- Wealth simple: no idea. Don't think they allow etransfers.
Security:
- TD: Security is okay. They have a standalone authenticator app, so they need to step it up, but sadly they are still one of the better ones in Canada.
- Simplii: Meh security. Normal passwords and SMS 2FA.
- Tangerine: Awful security. Your password can only be a 6 digit numerical pin. Thankfully they require 2FA but only using SMS.
- EQ: Meh security. Normal passwords and SMS 2FA.
- Wealth simple: Good security. TOTP available and I believe passkey is here or coming? Not sure about that last part, but I wouldn't be surprised with how ahead of the curve they are in this area.
Rewards:
- TD: Rewards depend on the credit card here.
- Simplii: Rewards are just in credit card.
- Tangerine: They have various rewards throughout the year. Usually temporary boosts to the interest on their savings account.
- EQ: Nope.
- Wealth simple: Nope.
Investing:
- TD: No idea.
- Simplii: no idea
- Tangerine: no idea
- EQ: Can buy GICs here but no idea otherwise.
- Wealth simple: The best since it's an investing service.
Misc:
- TD: Great customer support and very established. Has lots of options for accounts, cards, etc.
- Simplii: No in person access.
- Tangerine: No in persona access. Security is abysmal but the other services are pretty good.
- EQ: Typically has the highest interest rate of all Canadian banks for the savings account. No in person access.
- Wealth simple: Great for investing and a good service!
What I do: I have my everyday banking with TD, savings with EQ, and investing with Wealthsimple. When Tangerine gives a promo, I move my savings there until the promo expires, then I move it back to EQ. I have credit cards with a bunch, but the one I'm considering ditching is the Tangerine one since payments cannot be automated through another institution.