I have the same problem on mobile Firefox on Android. I'm using the default frontend as well. This was not happening a week ago (or maybe 10 days). Started recently.
this post was submitted on 08 Aug 2024
12 points (92.9% liked)
Programming.dev Meta
2489 readers
1 users here now
Welcome to the Programming.Dev meta community!
This is a community for discussing things about programming.dev itself. Things like announcements, site help posts, site questions, etc. are all welcome here.
Links
Credits
founded 2 years ago
MODERATORS
Do you have anything that would clear cookies or mess with the jwt you get from logging in in some way?
Not that I can think of. This just started this morning, and I haven't done or installed anything recently that might cause this. If it's only happening to me though....
Are you able to log in and stay logged in on one of the alternate frontends? E.g. https://a.programming.dev
Seems tied to my phone. Not happening on the desktop. Will try the alternate front end next. Then maybe reboot. 🤣
Ok, so pretty certain this is specific to my phone.
Browsed the recommended alternate front end for as long as I could stand it. Didn't get logged out, but I may have just not waited long enough.
Back on normal frontend, I deleted all browsing data (cookies, etc), logged back in and then got kicked out within a few minutes.
Rebooting the phone now. 🤞
Update: Nope, still getting booted within a few minutes. Beyond just using a different browser, I'm out of ideas, so I'll try that for a bit. 🤷
Update 2: Doesn't seem to be happening in Brave. So currently, only in FF, only on my phone, clearing cookies and rebooting did not help.
I'm open to any more ideas.
which firefox, stable beta or nightly
129.0 (Build #2016035991), hg-2d113ed75bf0+ GV: 129.0-20240801122119 AS: 129.0
Update: Haven't used my lemmy.world account in a while, so thought I'd test this out over there. Same thing happened after several minutes. Then I tried on Mastodon.world for a while and it seems to work fine. I'll try giving the alternate front end another round of testing later today.
Addendum: Can't reproduce the problem on t.programming.dev today, and couldn't seem to on a.programming.dev yesterday, so it seems to be specific to the default Lemmy front end.
so it sounds like default frontend, maybe tied to the version we have (we're still a few versions behind), only mobile ff.
I think I figured out how to reproduce it really quick.
- Log in to Lemmy on Firefox
- Switch to a different app
- Switch back to Firefox
- Reload the page.
Poof! I'm out. I repeated the test multiple times to confirm it's consistent. Probably actually getting kicked out on step 2. It's like FF decides to expire the Lemmy cookies when the app loses focus.
Armed with that info, I retested two alternate front ends on programming.dev (a. & t.) and default front end on lemmy.world and default front end on programming.drv with Brave. I was previously getting logged out on lemmy.world, but not now (maybe they updated something? Or my test is still flawed.). So, with these steps I can only reproduce it on programming.dev with the default front end on Firefox.
What OS are you using? Version of FF?
I seem to have isolated the problem to using a link to the website on the phone's home screen (created from FF using the "Add to Home screen" option in the three dots menu next to the address bar.
Starting that way seems to give any session cookies a very short life and they disappear quickly (logging me out). I created a bookmark within FF and have been using that and haven't been logged out since.
In fact, if I use the home screen link to programming.dev, FF doesn't think I'm logged in, but then if I use the bookmark from within that same instance of FF, it instantly sees me as already logged in.
Very strange.
Desktop FF here, been getting kicked off roughly once a day on default.
Not happening on Mlmym (old.), which I found to be better anyway. Wish I'd know about it before. Please keep it maintained!
I sorta remember this happened, or something like it, try actually clearing your cookies and logging in again. That might make it stick.
Good idea. Thanks.
Well, was a good idea, but alas, I deleted all browsing data (cookies, tabs, the whole shebang), logged back in and was kicked out within a few minutes.
Brought this same thing up in a post months ago and got quite a bit of downvotes and no help, so I never attempted to bring it up anymore lol. Maybe you'll have better luck. Saving this thread now... Thank you
The workaround I've been using is to just refresh the page. That tends to work... Sometimes... 🫠
I checked your post history, are you talking about this post from a year ago? https://programming.dev/post/749664 (that one has only a couple downvotes which usually is standard as most posts get a couple downvotes though)
Its the kind of thing thats very difficult to solve since not everyone gets it and seems like it pops up randomly (havent been able to clearly reproduce it yet)
Were you also on mobile firefox using the site? Or was the firefox you were using on pc
One thing that I get with Firefox is that usually by opening a link in background when switching I appear as logged out until I try several ways of refreshing.
Some days ago I was logged out for real, but that it is not so common for me.
This is a consistent problem for me
That was the first post. I posted another one a few months back that I've since deleted, which is probably why you can't see it.
I'm usually on mobile Brave browser on my Android. I'm always appearing to be logged out. But, sometimes, when I refresh, I'm suddenly automatically logged in. Other times I have to just login again.
Yup I realize its hard to to reproduce. Do you have a latest Android with mobile Brave browser you can test with?
I use an old android version but I can update to try to replicate
I haven't had any issues. Are you using the default lemmy client?
No, just good old fashioned Firefox. I've tried several clients and didn't really like any of them compared to the normal web interface. 🤷
Do you have any FF extensions that might be interfering somehow?
I have no extensions installed on my mobile Firefox. Maybe I should install some. 🤣
Same thing is happening to me on iPad OS’ Safari. Trying to come from sub.rehab, I had to login on any link coming from there. Refreshing usually didn’t work. The only think that I have here besides base Safari is AdGuard, which I hope it is not interfering or the instance is serving things that are ad-like